Over the years, professional wrestling has featured plenty of hair-versus-hair matches, including the night Raven lost his hair on September 17th, 2003.
But it’s rare for one to end with the loser bleeding from his head, or the person doing the shaving admitting he almost took off a piece of scalp by mistake.
That’s exactly what happened on September 17th, 2003, when NWA-TNA’s weekly pay-per-view ended with Raven losing his famous long hair to Shane Douglas.
He was then shaved on camera by a manager named Father James Mitchell, who used the wrong end of a pair of heavy-duty electric razors.
Raven Arrives in a Brand-New Company
TNA was barely a year old in fall 2003, still running weekly pay-per-views at the Nashville Fairgrounds building called The Asylum.
Raven, a wrestler who built his career on gothic, self-loathing anti-hero psychology in ECW and WCW, appeared early in the promotion’s life and did what he always did.
He rebuilt his old ECW stable, The Flock, under a new name. In TNA, it became The Gathering. It started small with Julio Dinero and Alexis Laree (the future Mickie James). CM Punk joined that spring while also working a separate, critically acclaimed program against Raven in Ring of Honor.
Raven’s chief antagonists in TNA were Father James Mitchell, a “sinister minister” manager character Mitchell had also played in ECW, and Mitchell’s stable, the Disciples of the New Church, which included Slash, Brian Lee, and Sinn Bodhi.
Mitchell debuted in TNA on June 19th, 2002, initially feuding with America’s Most Wanted. By 2003, his New Church had shifted focus onto Raven.
Mitchell also recruited Shane Douglas, “The Franchise,” to run interference, giving Raven two fronts to fight on at once.
Months of Buildup
The feud simmered for most of the year and made its direction clear. As early as March 9th, 2003, on the weekly pay-per-view, Mitchell teased the outcome directly to camera, promising that after teaching Raven about pain he would take his hair.
The promo ended with a live brawl where Douglas hacked off a chunk of Raven’s hair months early, previewing what was to come.
Through the summer, the story escalated on both regular programming and Raven’s parallel ROH run. On August 20th, 2003, Raven won the Lucky 13 Gauntlet Match to become the number-one contender to AJ Styles’ NWA World Heavyweight Championship.
He lost the title match a week later, with Douglas, Slash, and Sinn all involved at ringside. On September 3rd, Raven’s team—himself, Jeff Jarrett, D’Lo Brown, and America’s Most Wanted—beat Douglas’s side in a War Games match.
Three days later, on September 6th in ROH, Raven beat CM Punk in a Clockwork Orange Cage Match. The match ended with Punk crucifying Raven against the cage in an X shape.
By TNA’s September 17th weekly pay-per-view, Raven had endured a full month of the most physically brutal stretch of his year.
The Match and the Shocking Debut
The hair-versus-hair stipulation was set for that show, taped at The Asylum and airing as NWA-TNA Weekly PPV #63.
Raven and Douglas had their match, which was going as TNA’s booking had signalled for months—until a masked, face-painted figure ran in.
It was Vampiro, making his surprise TNA debut, interfering directly on Douglas’s behalf and helping him beat Raven.
Would someone be leaving the Asylum bald when Raven faced Shane Douglas?
Vampiro’s arrival wasn’t just a one-off angle; it kicked off a legitimate personal rivalry between him and Raven that later spilled backstage into a real fight. The fight left Vampiro with a torn ACL, according to Raven’s own biographical record of the period.
The Night Raven Lost His Hair — and Almost His Scalp
The Scalping
Here the angle stopped looking like ordinary wrestling theatre. With Douglas’s win secured, Father James Mitchell took charge of the head-shaving live on camera, using what he later described as heavy-duty shears meant for shearing sheep rather than barber’s clippers.
In a candid interview, Mitchell explained what went wrong: he was holding the shears backward without realizing it. The mistake meant he was peeling Raven’s scalp off rather than cutting his hair.
The broadcast caught a small piece of flesh visibly falling from Raven’s head during the shave—footage that, by Mitchell’s own account, made him feel physically ill when he watched it at home.
The injury wasn’t a work. Mitchell said Raven needed three to four weeks away from television to heal from what had happened, a legitimate medical gap built into the storyline’s aftermath.
What followed backstage became as talked-about as the angle itself. When Raven came through the curtain, furious and bleeding, he confronted Mitchell directly, got in his face, cursed him out, cocked back to hit him, then pulled the punch at the last second.
Instead, according to Mitchell, Raven wiped some of his own blood off his head and shoved a handful of it into Mitchell’s face.
The two reportedly patched things up afterward—Raven apologized for the shove, Mitchell for the botched shave that had hurt him.
Why It Mattered to the Story
None of this happened in a vacuum. TNA’s booking had spent months building Raven as a man picked apart piece by piece by Mitchell’s stable: his title shots, allies, and now, literally, his hair.
The angle gave Mitchell’s Disciples of the New Church its signature moment, even as the stable was on its last legs; the group formally disbanded about two weeks later, on October 1st, 2003.
It also cemented Vampiro as a legitimate new threat rather than a one-off surprise, setting up a program between him and Raven that ran for months afterward, including a bloody “Blood Gallows of Retribution” match later that fall.
Raven’s Revenge
Raven didn’t take the loss lying down, on-screen or off. Over the following weeks, he hunted down and beat members of the New Church one by one—Slash, Sinn, and eventually Mitchell himself.
The receipts came due on November 5th, 2003, when Raven beat Father James Mitchell in a bloody Last Man Standing match, closing the feud that had cost him his hair two months earlier.
Mitchell delivered a strong final promo insisting Raven couldn’t outthink him, before the two had a big, bloody brawl that ended with Raven busting Mitchell open.
What Happened to Raven in TNA After
The hair Raven lost that night never fully defined his TNA run. The promotion kept finding new ways to put him through the wringer.
The Gathering turned on him that December when CM Punk and Julio Dinero, the two men who’d spent over a year as his most loyal disciples, helped Abyss and Kevin Northcutt beat him down in a six-man cage match, then aligned with Mitchell.
Raven spent the following months feuding with his former protégés and continuing to clash with Mitchell and Vampiro into early 2004, including a tag match where Terry Funk took a stun-gun shock meant for Raven, throwing himself in front of Mitchell’s weapon to protect him.
Raven’s time in the company wasn’t linear from there. He drifted in and out of TNA’s weekly cards through the mid-2000s, feuding with Abyss (under Mitchell’s management again, starting in 2005) and later forming and leading the Serotonin stable in 2006 and 2007, a younger heel faction modelled on his old Flock and Gathering groups.
He remained a fixture of the company’s hardcore and gimmick-match scene for years, working programs with names like Rhino and continuing to appear on Impact television into the back half of the decade before his run wound down.
The Legacy of One Bad Angle
Two decades later, the September 17th, 2003, scalping remains one of the stranger footnotes in TNA’s early history, a moment where a scripted hair match turned into a genuine, if minor, on-camera injury, and where the manager responsible for it was candid enough afterward to explain, in detail, exactly how he’d messed it up.
It’s not remembered as a classic match. It’s remembered because it’s one of the rare times when a wrestling angle’s behind-the-scenes reality was arguably more dramatic than the fiction it was supposed to sell.
Sources
